Download our SSCE Study Guide Bundle
Chapter 13 Summary of The Mayor of Casterbridge
Michael Henchard rents a comfortable cottage in the western part of Casterbridge for Susan (who goes by the name Mrs. Newson) and Elizabeth-Jane. Once they are installed, Henchard begins visiting them frequently, playing the part of a suitor to keep up appearances. Henchard approaches this courtship not with romantic passion, but with a “business-like determination” to fulfil his strict moral duty to Susan, regardless of his own sentiments or the woman he left in Jersey.
One afternoon, while Elizabeth-Jane is out, Henchard bluntly asks Susan to name the wedding day. Susan smiles faintly; she finds no joy in the elaborate deception she has entered into, but Henchard reassures her that his brilliant new manager, Farfrae, has given him the free time necessary to pursue this.
The townspeople soon notice the powerful Mayor’s regular visits to the pale, fragile widow—whom the local boys cruelly dub “The Ghost”—and marvel at his uncharacteristic interest in a woman. Henchard pushes forward with the wedding preparations with a “dogged, unflinching spirit.” He is motivated by three main resolves: to make amends to Susan, to provide a home for Elizabeth-Jane, and to actively castigate himself by lowering his public dignity through marrying a woman of comparatively humble standing.
The wedding takes place on a damp, misty November morning, with Donald Farfrae acting as the groomsman. Farfrae is the only person present besides the bride and groom who knows the true history of the couple. Outside the church, a group of the town’s working-class citizens—including Christopher Coney, Nance Mockridge, Mother Cuxsom, and Solomon Longways—gather to observe and gossip. They discuss Henchard’s humble beginnings as a “poor parish ‘prentice” and marvel at the immense wealth he has acquired. As the newly married couple departs in a plain carriage, Nance Mockridge observes a “blue-beardy look” about Henchard and predicts Susan will suffer, though others argue his wealth makes him a godsend for a poor woman. The idlers then disperse, deciding to head to the Three Mariners inn to drink.
Analysis of Chapter 13
Henchard’s second marriage to Susan is entirely stripped of romantic love. He approaches it with “business-like determination” and a “dogged, unflinching spirit.” For Henchard, the reunion is a calculated act of moral restitution. He actively views the lowering of his dignity in marrying a “comparatively humble” woman as a form of self-castigation and a “thorn” he must endure to punish his past sins. This reinforces Henchard’s transactional view of morality; he is attempting to balance the scales of his conscience.
The entire courtship is an elaborate, staged performance designed to protect Elizabeth-Jane from the truth and preserve Henchard’s public image. While Elizabeth-Jane is completely “hoodwinked” by the arrangement, Susan finds the deception deeply uncomfortable and does not enjoy the pleasantries of their fake courtship. This highlights the fragile foundation of their new life. It establishes that Henchard’s restored family is built entirely on secrets and false appearances.
Hardy heavily utilises the town’s working-class characters—Christopher Coney, Mother Cuxsom, Solomon Longways, and Nance Mockridge—as a Greek chorus. Their earthy, pragmatic commentary provides a sharp contrast to Henchard’s stiff, secretive world. Through their gossip, Hardy reveals Henchard’s original poverty as a “parish ‘prentice” and subtly foreshadows potential marital strife with Nance Mockridge’s observation of Henchard’s ominous “blue-beardy look.” Their banter grounds the novel in the daily realities of the peasant class.
Farfrae’s role as groomsman and the sole keeper of the family’s secret (aside from the principals) underscores how indispensable he has become to Henchard. Henchard even boasts to Susan that Farfrae’s splendid management allows him the free time to pursue the marriage. It shows that Henchard’s personal and professional lives are both currently being heavily buoyed by the young Scotchman.
Chapter 14 Summary of The Mayor of Casterbridge
Chapter 14 of The Mayor of Casterbridge opens with Susan and Elizabeth-Jane settling comfortably into Henchard’s large house. They are enjoying a “Martinmas summer” of peace and prosperity. This newfound affluence and lack of stress cause a remarkable physical transformation in Elizabeth-Jane; her thin face and figure round out, her skin clears, and she develops a beautiful, blooming complexion. Despite her new wealth, however, Elizabeth-Jane is governed by a strict inner “reasonableness” and a “field-mouse fear of the coulter of destiny.” Accustomed to poverty and hardship, she actively suppresses any urge to dress gaudily or flaunt her status. Instead, she prefers a plain dark dress and a simple sunshade to protect her new complexion.
Henchard grows increasingly fond of his supposed daughter, though a moment of tension arises when he observes her hair is light brown. He remarks to Susan that he remembered baby Elizabeth-Jane’s hair promising to be black. Susan is visibly startled and uneasy at this observation, but Henchard brushes it off, assuming hair simply lightens as children grow. Henchard then insists that Elizabeth-Jane officially take his surname, dropping “Newson.” Susan tentatively asks the girl to agree, but when Elizabeth-Jane carefully questions Henchard about whether he truly wishes it, his temper flares at what he perceives as women making an “ado… about a trifle”; he abruptly tells her to do whatever she pleases, and the subject is dropped.
Meanwhile, Donald Farfrae is revolutionising Henchard’s business. He replaces Henchard’s crude, old-fashioned methods of chalk-strokes and memory with modern ledgers and letters. Henchard displays a “tigerish affection” for his new manager. He treats him like a younger brother and insists on his constant companionship, though he occasionally exhibits a tendency to domineer which Farfrae politely resists.
The chapter concludes with a mysterious incident. Both Elizabeth-Jane and Farfrae receive anonymous notes asking them to come to a granary on Durnover Hill. They arrive separately, realise they have both been tricked by the same hoax, and wait awkwardly in the barn as it begins to rain. To break the tension, they converse, and Farfrae delicately blows the wheat husks out of Elizabeth-Jane’s hair and clothes. He offers to fetch her an umbrella, but she declines and quickly leaves; Farfrae follows slowly, thoughtfully whistling a tune.
Analysis of Chapter 14
Elizabeth-Jane is characterised by her profound inner restraint. Even when elevated to wealth, she refuses to indulge in the frivolous fashions of the other Casterbridge girls because her early experiences with poverty have ingrained in her a deep “field-mouse fear” of sudden ruin. She views light-heartedness as “irrational.” This proves that her worldview is inherently tragic and cautious. This pragmatism ensures that she remains grounded, but it also highlights how deeply her past trauma continues to govern her present happiness.
Hardy drops a massive hint regarding the novel’s central dramatic irony during the discussion about Elizabeth-Jane’s hair colour. Henchard’s casual memory that the baby’s hair was dark, contrasted with the current Elizabeth-Jane’s light brown hair, causes Susan intense, hidden panic. This heavily foreshadows the upcoming revelation that the child Henchard sold actually died, and that the current Elizabeth-Jane is biologically Richard Newson’s daughter.
Henchard’s relationships are dictated by extremes. In business, he develops an almost overbearing, “tigerish” love for Farfrae, demanding his constant presence as a companion rather than treating him as a simple employee. In his domestic life, his attempt to formally give Elizabeth-Jane his name fails purely because of his volatile temper. The moment she hesitates, his pride is wounded; he dismisses the entire emotional endeavour as a “trifle” and stubbornly refuses to push the matter further. This shows how his impulsivity actively sabotages his own desires.
Farfrae’s management style serves as a microcosm for the agricultural and industrial shifts of the 19th century. He completely sweeps away Henchard’s “rugged” and picturesque viva voce system of business—where deals were struck by memory and a handshake—and implements a modern, systematic approach using “ciphering and mensuration.” Farfrae represents the new, scientific era that will inevitably outpace Henchard’s traditional, brute-force methods.
The final scene in the Durnover granary establishes a delicate romantic tension between Farfrae and Elizabeth-Jane. The anonymous note acts as an external catalyst to force the two reserved characters into an intimate, isolated space. Farfrae’s gentle act of blowing the chaff from her hair and dress is highly intimate and domestic. It marks the first concrete shift in their relationship from mere acquaintances towards budding affection.
Chapter 15 Summary of The Mayor of Casterbridge
Chapter of The Mayor of Casterbridge begins by focusing on Elizabeth-Jane, who, under the influence of her new, comfortable life and her budding attraction to Donald Farfrae, begins to pay more attention to her appearance. Though she initially resolved to remain simple in her dress, she falls into the “insidious” trap of buying a complete, stylish outfit to match a pair of delicately-tinted gloves her father gave her. Despite being admired as the town beauty, her modesty prevails; she feels inadequate and wishes she could trade her finery for books and education so she would not be despised for her lack of accomplishments.
Meanwhile, the strong friendship between Henchard and Farfrae begins to fracture over a disciplinary issue. A young, round-shouldered worker named Abel Whittle has an inveterate habit of oversleeping and arriving late for work. After several warnings, an infuriated Henchard threatens that if Whittle is late one more time, he will personally drag the boy out of bed.
When Whittle fails to appear at four o’clock the next morning, Henchard makes good on his threat. He marches to Whittle’s cottage, wakes him, and forces him to go to work in the yard without his breeches. When Farfrae arrives and sees the half-naked, terrified Whittle, he is appalled and immediately orders the boy to go home and dress. Henchard overhears this and countermands the order, insisting the punishment must stand. Farfrae firmly declares that the “joke has been carried far enough.” He calls Henchard’s actions “tyrannical,” and threatens to quit on the spot if his order is not obeyed.
Henchard backs down, but is deeply hurt. He accuses Farfrae of taking advantage of the shameful secrets he had confided in him, though Farfrae simply replies he had forgotten all about them. Henchard becomes moody and sullen.
The shift in power becomes even more apparent later that day when a child arrives asking for Mr. Farfrae to come and value a haystack. Henchard questions the child and learns that the townspeople greatly prefer Farfrae because he is “cleverer,” “better tempered,” and the “most understanding man.” The locals even openly wish that Farfrae were the master instead of Henchard. Though Henchard and Farfrae walk together later and attempt to smooth things over, Henchard is left with a “dim dread” of the young Scotchman. He deeply regrets that he ever confided the secrets of his life to him.
Analysis of Chapter 15
The incident with Abel Whittle perfectly illustrates the fundamental differences between Henchard and Farfrae. Henchard represents an antiquated, feudal style of leadership; he relies on brute force, public humiliation, and volatile temper to control his men. In stark contrast, Farfrae represents modern, enlightened management. He views Henchard’s punishment as “tyrannical” and prioritises human dignity. He recognises that humiliating a worker does not produce better results. Farfrae’s empathy easily wins the loyalty of the workers.
This chapter of The Mayor of Casterbridge marks the beginning of Henchard’s downfall at the hands of his own protégé. The public confrontation forces Henchard to realise that he has surrendered his absolute authority. Farfrae’s willingness to resign rather than permit cruelty proves that he operates on a stronger moral foundation than the Mayor. Furthermore, Henchard’s paranoia causes him to conflate Farfrae’s moral stand with a personal betrayal. He accuses Farfrae of using his past sins against him. This shows how Henchard’s past guilt continually poisons his present relationships.
Hardy uses the rustic chorus—relayed through the innocent honesty of a child—to demonstrate how quickly Henchard is being eclipsed. Hearing that his own community calls him a “fool” compared to Farfrae, and that they wish Farfrae were the master, is a devastating blow to Henchard’s massive pride. The very man Henchard impulsively hired to save his business is now passively conquering the town’s affections. This sets the stage for their inevitable, bitter rivalry.
While the men battle for dominance, Elizabeth-Jane’s character is further developed through her relationship with vanity. She is self-aware enough to recognise the slippery slope of materialism (how buying gloves necessitates buying a matching bonnet, then a dress, then a parasol). However, her “field-mouse fear” of fate keeps her grounded. Even when admired, she mourns her lack of intellectual “accomplishments,” showing that she values substance over superficial beauty. This quiet stoicism makes her a quiet observer of the tragedy unfolding around her.
Related:
- Chapter 1 to 3 Summary and Analysis of The Mayor of Casterbridge by Thomas Hardy
- Chapter 4 to 6 Summary and Analysis of The Mayor of Casterbridge by Thomas Hardy
- Chapter 7 to 12 Summary and Analysis of The Mayor of Casterbridge by Thomas Hardy
- Chapter 16 to 18 Summary and Analysis of The Mayor of Casterbridge by Thomas Hardy
- Chapter 19 to 24 Summary and Analysis of The Mayor of Casterbridge by Thomas Hardy
- Chapter 25 to 27 Summary and Analysis of The Mayor of Casterbridge by Thomas Hardy
- Chapter 28 to 30 Summary and Analysis of The Mayor of Casterbridge by Thomas Hardy
- Chapter 31 to 33 Summary and Analysis of The Mayor of Casterbridge by Thomas Hardy
- Chapter 34 to 36 Summary and Analysis of The Mayor of Casterbridge by Thomas Hardy
- Chapter 37 to 39 Summary and Analysis of The Mayor of Casterbridge by Thomas Hardy
- Chapter 40 to 42 Summary and Analysis of The Mayor of Casterbridge by Thomas Hardy
- Chapter 43 to 45 Summary and Analysis of The Mayor of Casterbridge by Thomas Hardy
Receive Literary Updates through our Social Media Channels:
- WhatsApp: Literature PADI or Literature-in-English with LP
- Telegram: Literature PADI
- YouTube: @literaturepadi
- Facebook: Literature PADI
